The Kratom Council

Latest / Regulation

Regulation

Kratom Keeps Getting Blamed For What The Concentrates Do. Apple Seeds Contain A Compound That Releases Cyanide, Nobody Has Ever Tried To Ban Apples, And That Is The Whole Argument.

A flat pale plaster wall photographed straight on in soft warm daylight, with three identical rectangular recesses cut into it in a row across the frame, all the same size and all at the same height. A single slender polished brass strip runs horizontally across the full width of the wall, level with the bottom edge of the recesses. The left recess is empty and shows bare plaster. The middle recess holds one thin flat brass sheet lying on its floor. The right recess is filled with brass flush to the face of the wall. Nothing else appears, and no markings or lettering appear anywhere.

A man dies. A laboratory finds a kratom alkaloid in his blood. The headline says kratom.

That sentence is doing a lot of work and most of it is hidden. It does not say whether he drank leaf tea or swallowed a concentrated tablet holding many times more of one alkaloid than any leaf has ever carried. Those are different products. They are made differently, they are sold differently, and the federal government already regulates them differently. The headline flattens all of it into one word, and the word is the name of a plant.

There is a clean way to see the problem, and it has nothing to do with kratom. It has to do with apples.

What Is Actually In A Kratom Leaf

The leaf of the kratom tree contains dozens of alkaloids. The main one is mitragynine. A second one, 7-hydroxymitragynine, usually shortened to 7-OH, is in the leaf as well, but only in tiny amounts. That is the natural profile of the plant and it has been the natural profile for as long as anyone has measured it.

Many products sold in the last few years look nothing like that. They are made by concentrating the plant's alkaloids, or by chemically altering one of them into something new. The federal notice of intent published on October 14, which this publication retrieved and read in full, describes a study of products sold online and reports that "alkaloid concentrations for these marketed products were often higher than those in naturally occurring Mitragyna speciosa leaves."

Higher than the leaf. That is the whole story in four words. What is hurting people is not the leaf. It is what happens when somebody concentrates the leaf's chemistry into a form the plant never produced.

Now The Apples

Apple seeds contain a compound called amygdalin. So do apricot kernels, peach pits and cherry stones. Amygdalin releases hydrogen cyanide when it breaks down. This is ordinary chemistry and nobody disputes it.

In the 1970s people concentrated amygdalin into a product called Laetrile and sold it as a cancer cure. The Food and Drug Administration moved against it. The case reached the Supreme Court of the United States, which decided it in 1979, and this publication retrieved that opinion and read it in full.

Here is the part worth sitting with. The Court wrote down, as a plain finding of fact, that the compound at the centre of the case was "a glucoside present in the kernels or seeds of most fruits."

Most fruits. The government had it in writing, in front of the highest court in the country, that the source of the dangerous product was sitting in the produce aisle. And then nothing happened to the produce aisle. No apple ban. No apricot ban. No warning label on a bag of cherries. The restriction landed on the concentrated preparation and stopped there, and in the forty-seven years since, nobody has seriously proposed anything else.

One caution, because this publication would rather state a limit than let a reader overreach. The Court in 1979 was answering a narrow question about whether the law's safety rules applied to terminally ill patients. It was not asked about food and it decided nothing about food. What the case shows is where the government aimed, not a ruling that it could never aim anywhere else.

The Law Is Not Soft On Cyanide. It Is Precise About Where It Aims.

It would be easy to read all that and conclude American regulators simply shrug at cyanide. The opposite is true, and the contrast is the point.

When somebody manufactures hydrogen cyanide as an industrial chemical, the law is severe. It sits on the federal list of regulated toxic substances under the Clean Air Act, by name and by chemical identifier, with a threshold quantity of 2,500 pounds. The list records why it is there, and the reason given is "Mandated for listing by Congress."

Congress named it. Not an agency reading between the lines, not a regulator stretching a definition. The legislature put that specific chemical on that specific list.

So the same legal system does both things at once. It names the manufactured chemical and regulates it tightly. It leaves the apple alone. The difference is not squeamishness or inconsistency. It is that the law aims at the thing that is dangerous and not at every plant that happens to contain a trace of its starting material, because almost everything in a grocery store contains a trace of something.

The Government Has Already Said This About Kratom

This is the part that keeps getting lost. The federal agencies acting on 7-OH have been explicit that they are not acting on the leaf.

When the Justice Department announced the scheduling order that took effect on August 26, it said the action "is directed at deliberately manufactured and concentrated opioid products, not traditional botanical kratom." The separate proposal covering 7-OH carries the same message, stating that it is "not intended to apply to natural kratom leaf containing only naturally occurring trace levels of 7-OH."

Read those two sentences next to the apple case and they are the same sentence. The concentrate is the target. The plant is not.

Federal regulators also drew the line with numbers instead of adjectives. The October notice proposes control above one milligram of 7-OH per gram of product, or where the amount of mitragynine divided by the amount of 7-OH falls below one hundred to one. A laboratory can run that test. A leaf passes it and a fortified tablet does not. Philadelphia, whose own ordinance takes effect on November 12, drew its line at 2 percent of a product's total alkaloids, which is a different number measured a different way but the same idea.

Three separate authorities, all of them drawing a line through the middle of the category rather than around the outside of it.

Why The Headline Keeps Getting It Wrong Anyway

There is a technical reason the public record is muddier than it looks, and this publication has reported it at length before.

Most laboratories test for mitragynine, because mitragynine is the marker for kratom use. The Food and Drug Administration's own scientific assessment of 7-OH says what follows from that: "Many forensic laboratories test for mitragynine as a marker of kratom use. In these cases, 7-OH overdose cases and fatalities may incorrectly be classified as kratom and/or mitragynine-related."

So a death driven by a concentrated product can enter the record under the name of the plant. Not through anybody's bad faith. Through the test that was run.

That cuts both ways and this publication has said so before. It does not mean deaths recorded as kratom were secretly caused by concentrates. It means the label on the record is less certain than the confidence with which it gets quoted.

One City Went The Other Way

Not every lawmaker has drawn the line where the federal government drew it. A proposed ordinance in East Peoria, Illinois, which this publication retrieved and read, defines kratom to include "any parts of the plant Mitragnya speciosa, whether growing or not" along with the compounds made from it. The misspelling of the plant's name is in the document itself.

That definition puts the leaf and the concentrate in one sentence and treats them as one problem. It is the apple ban that 1979 declined to write. Whether it ever became law could not be established, because the copy the city publishes carries a blank date and empty vote lines, and the only record found is of a first reading in October 2025.

Where This Comparison Stops

An argument like this is only worth making if it is honest about its limits, so here are three.

Cyanide and kratom alkaloids are not alike. Their chemistry is different, their effects are different, and nothing here compares the two as substances. The comparison is about how laws get written and nothing else.

Nothing here says kratom is safe. This publication takes no position on that question. Kratom is not approved by the Food and Drug Administration for any use, the agency maintains a warning to consumers about it, and the government's findings about concentrated 7-OH products are serious, are its own, and are not disputed in this article.

And source material is not automatically untouchable. Raw bitter apricot kernels sold as food have drawn warning letters and consumer advice of their own. So the honest claim is narrower than a slogan. When a dangerous thing is made by concentrating a plant's chemistry, American regulators have reliably aimed at the concentrate. In the clearest case on record, they did not go after the fruit.

What To Ask Next Time

When the next headline says kratom, one question sits underneath it. Leaf, or concentrate

If the answer is a concentrated product, the story is about a manufactured item the federal government has already named, measured and moved against. It is a real story and a serious one. It is just not a story about a plant.

Sourcing, Plainly

Four documents were retrieved and read in full for this article. The Supreme Court's 1979 opinion came from the Library of Congress scan of the United States Reports. The federal notice of intent of October 14 and the federal list of regulated toxic substances both came from the Government Publishing Office. The East Peoria ordinance came from the city's own agenda system. The Justice Department statement, the natural leaf assurance and the Food and Drug Administration assessment of 7-OH are quoted from this publication's own earlier articles, which retrieved them.

Two statements are reported rather than retrieved and carry no quotation marks: the regulatory attention paid to raw apricot kernels sold as food, and the basic chemistry of amygdalin. Neither one carries the argument.

Sources

  1. Library of Congress — United States v. Rutherford, 442 U.S. 544 (1979), United States Reports volume 442 (retrieved and read in full)
  2. Government Publishing Office — Federal Register document 2026-20943, notice of intent of October 14, 2026 (retrieved and read in full)
  3. Government Publishing Office — 40 CFR 68.130, the federal list of regulated toxic substances and threshold quantities, July 1, 2024 edition (retrieved and read)
  4. City of East Peoria, Illinois — Ordinance No. 4871, from the city's agenda system (retrieved and read in full)
  5. The Kratom Council — why a death caused by 7-OH can end up recorded as mitragynine
  6. The Kratom Council — DEA schedules three 7-OH analogs, carrying the Justice Department statement
  7. The Kratom Council — before 7-OH there was Spice, carrying the federal assurance about natural leaf
  8. The Kratom Council — the same distinction drawn with caffeine
  9. The Kratom Council — Pennsylvania's two chambers and the numbers in play

← Back to all coverage

Get new reporting by email